Motivating The Project Team: What Would You Do Differently?

  • Motivating The Project Team: What Would You Do Differently?

    Profile photo of User

    Courses IPM IPM

    Courses at IPM,October 30, 2024 at 1:07 pm

    Motivating a team is one of the most important and most difficult parts of project leadership, and sometimes the fastest way to learn what works is to see what doesn’t. 

    Watch the video above, which shows a team leader named Cara motivating her team badly. As you watch, take notes on as many problems as you can spot in how she leads. No theory needed – your own experience of being led well, or badly, is enough. 

    Then share one action Cara could take to improve how she leads and motivates her team, and briefly explain why you think it would help. 

    Once you’ve posted, read what others have suggested and reply with your thoughts. Do you agree their suggestion would make a difference, or is there a different action you would put first? Please keep your comments constructive and focus on behaviours rather than the person. 

    Taking the Project Leadership & Management Diploma course? Post one action with your reasoning, and reply to at least two other posts. 

  • 11 Replies
    Jump to latest reply

Share this Discussion with Your Linkedln Connections

Your Discussion is Live

Share it on LinkedIn to invite more professionals into the conversation.

Share on LinkedIn
  • Ivy BakerFlag

    Project Manager at BlueBird International, 15 Nov 2024 at 01:36 PM

    Unclear Vision and Objectives:

    • Cara has set an ambitious goal of cutting operating costs by 50% without impacting performance or output but has not provided a clear plan or framework for achieving this.

    Underutilization of Team Members:

    • Some team members do not have enough work, indicating a lack of task delegation and workload distribution.

    Lack of Clear Role Definitions:

    • Team members do not know whom to approach for help, highlighting a lack of clarity in roles and responsibilities.

    Avoidance of Conflict:

    • Cara avoids addressing conflicts within the team, leaving issues unresolved and potentially damaging team morale and productivity.

    Neglect of Professional Development:

    • Refusing a team member’s request for training on critical software undermines individual development and can impact the team’s ability to deliver effectively.

     

    Suggested Action for Cara

    Cara should develop a comprehensive project framework with clear goals, role definitions, and opportunities for growth to address the team’s challenges. She should break down the ambitious goal of cutting operating costs by 50% into smaller, actionable milestones with defined timelines and share this roadmap with the team to ensure alignment and clarity. To address underutilization, Cara can conduct a skills assessment to assign tasks matching team members’ expertise while balancing workloads equitably. Defining roles and responsibilities through tools like a RACI matrix will help team members understand who to approach for support and improve collaboration. Cara must also tackle conflicts directly by fostering an open-door policy and mediating disputes promptly to maintain team morale and productivity. Additionally, she should support professional development by allowing team members to attend short, impactful training sessions to enhance their skills and contributions. These steps will help Cara create a cohesive, motivated team capable of achieving the project’s ambitious objectives.

    • Sophia AdamFlag

      Project Manager at Cygma, 15 Nov 2024 at 02:53 PM

      Cara’s situation highlights critical areas where effective leadership practices can make a significant difference. Developing a clear project framework with actionable milestones is essential for aligning the team and maintaining focus. I particularly like the suggestion of using a RACI matrix to define roles and improve collaboration—it’s a practical tool that can address confusion about responsibilities. Allowing team members opportunities for professional development, even through short-term training, would boost morale and enhance the team’s capabilities. Tackling conflicts head-on and fostering an open communication culture will ensure issues are resolved constructively, creating a more productive and harmonious work environment. Just to add, I would like to ask some questions.

      How can Cara prioritize building trust within her team, especially given her current reliance on email communication?

      What steps can Cara take to foster stronger engagement and motivation among team members, particularly for those feeling underutilized?

      Are there any specific team-building activities or techniques that might work better than informal gatherings like pub drinks?

    • How could Cara balance the project’s ambitious objectives with realistic expectations to avoid overwhelming the team?
  • Julie RomanenghiFlag

    Director of Payment Integrity at Carelon Global Solutions Ireland, 07 May 2025 at 12:32 PM

    There are so many things Cara needs to do differently that it’s challenging to select just one. The root cause of all of the issues is her disengagement/lack of leadership beyond selecting the team members. To course correct, she needs to pull the team together to gather and assess ideas to meet their target and plan next steps, including defining roles, responsibilities, and tracking protocols. This should be done in person with steps taken to ensure an audit trail (i.e., meeting notes rather than precluding in person interaction in favor of emails).

  • Sophia AdamFlag

    Project Manager at Cygma, 15 Nov 2024 at 02:50 PM

    Identified Problems

    1. Unrealistic Goal Setting:

      • Cutting operating costs by 50% without impacting performance or output is a highly ambitious goal that lacks a clear plan or feasibility analysis.
    2. Lack of Defined Roles and Responsibilities:

      • Cara assumes that the team of experts will “find a way” to work together without assigning specific roles or providing guidance.
    3. Lack of Confidence in Leadership:

      • Cara shares her insecurities about the project with a team member, undermining her authority and potentially affecting team morale.
    4. Over-Reliance on Email Communication:

      • By restricting communication to email and copying herself on all correspondence, Cara limits collaboration and fosters a bureaucratic environment.
    5. Underutilized Team Members:

      • Some team members report not having enough work, indicating poor workload distribution and project planning.
    6. Lack of Support for Team Members:

      • Team members needing assistance are not provided with proper guidance, leaving them to struggle or guess whom to approach.
    7. Avoidance of Conflict:

      • Cara avoids addressing disputes among team members, potentially worsening team dynamics and reducing productivity.
    8. Superficial Team-Building Efforts:

      • The proposed team-building activity (pub drinks) is unstructured and might not cater to everyone’s preferences or foster real collaboration.
    9. Denial of Necessary Training:

      • Declining a training request for critical software negatively impacts the project, as the team member cannot perform effectively.

    One Action Cara Could Take

    Action: Implement structured leadership and team-building initiatives.

    Cara could organize a kick-off workshop to define:

    • Clear project goals, deliverables, and success criteria.
    • Roles and responsibilities of each team member.
    • Communication protocols (e.g., regular team meetings instead of relying solely on email).
    • A plan to address conflicts and challenges collaboratively.

    This workshop would allow Cara to set the tone as a confident and supportive leader, encourage open communication, and motivate the team by giving them a sense of ownership in the project.

    • Alessandra Heggenstaller

      Project Manager at SETU, 02 Dec 2024 at 01:48 PM

      Do you think Cara should take some time to get to know her team better before conducting her Kick-off workshop? From the video clip, it seems she was unaware of the team’s individual roles and the line management structure. By familiarising herself with her team’s expertise and responsibilities within the organisation, she would be able to assign tasks more effectively and accurately, leading to smoother progress towards achieving the project deliverables.

    • Conor Maloney

      Operations Manager at University College Dublin, 18 Feb 2025 at 02:08 PM

      Identified Challenges

      Unrealistic Goal: The objective of reducing operating costs by 50% lacks a clear project plan.

      Undefined Roles: There is an assumption of expertise among team members without adequate guidance.

      Leadership Concerns: There is a noticeable lack of belief in the team’s capabilities.

      Trust Deficiencies: Micromanagement, including a desire for oversight on all email communications, undermines trust and creates ambiguity in line management.

      Insufficient Team Support: Tasks are not delegated effectively, and there is limited understanding of team members’ roles within the organizational structure.

      Conflict Avoidance: There is an absence of effective conflict management skills and resolution strategies.

      Ineffective Team Building: Current team-building efforts, such as casual outings, may not adequately foster collaboration and inclusivity, particularly for members with personal commitments.

      Neglect of Professional Development: Training requests require careful review, especially for software essential to organizational operations and project efficiency.

      Recommendations for Improvement:

      I believe it would be really beneficial for Cara to develop a revised project plan that includes detailed timelines. This will help keep open lines of communication about any concerns and ensure that the workload is distributed effectively. I also think Cara should focus on upskilling and creating more opportunities for professional development, as this will add great value to the team.

      Furthermore, introducing some meaningful team-building initiatives could greatly enhance trust and collaboration.

  • Julie RomanenghiFlag

    Director of Payment Integrity at Carelon Global Solutions Ireland, 07 May 2025 at 12:58 PM

    There are so many things Cara needs to do differently that it’s challenging to select just one. The root cause of all of the issues is her disengagement/lack of leadership beyond selecting the team members. To course correct, she needs to pull the team together to gather and assess ideas to meet their target and plan next steps, including defining roles, responsibilities, and tracking protocols. This should be done in person with steps taken to ensure an audit trail (i.e., meeting notes rather than precluding in person interaction in favor of emails).

    She also needs to understand what is happening within the team and provide support for team members encountering challenges in identifying resources and facing intra-team conflict. This needs to be done in a way that is respectful of the team’s time (i.e., not by pulling them together on a Friday evening when they may have personal commitments).

  • Björn Höjing BurleFlag

    Designation at MIAN Minds AB, 21 Jul 2025 at 09:46 AM

    Unrealistic goal setting without a real plan

    Cara opens the project by presenting a goal: cutting operating costs by 50% with no negative impact on performance or output. She frames this as the most important project in the company’s history.

    Reflection: This isn’t leadership – it’s wishful thinking. Cara doesn’t seem to understand what the project actually involves. She’s only focusing on the outcome and pushes straight for it without having a clue how to get there. No roadmap, no milestones, no structure. Just vibes.

    No framework, no PMO setup, no support

    She tells the team, “You’re all experts – just work together and figure something out.”

    Reflection: This is wild. She clearly lacks a project plan, there’s no PMO structure, no clear breakdown of responsibilities, no check-ins, no sign of a RACI matrix or role mapping. Just a hope that something magical will happen if they sit in the same room.

    Communication breakdown

    Cara insists that all communication must go through email, and that she should be CC’d on everything “for audit trail purposes.”

    Reflection: Instead of making herself available, she hides behind email – a clear sign of someone who’s afraid to lead. It sends the message that she either doesn’t trust the team or wants to control everything. Also, when everyone is physically in the same space, using email for everything just slows things down and kills team dynamics.

    Admits She Doesn’t Know What She’s Doing

    She has a one-on-one coffee with a team member and literally says she doesn’t know what she’s doing or what the project is.

    Reflection: What a mess. Admitting this to a team member, instead of a coach or mentor, will destroy trust. Rumors will spread. This shows poor judgement and signals insecurity – she doesn’t trust herself, and clearly doesn’t believe in her own leadership.

    Team is idle – She doesn’t notice

    The team is sitting around waiting for instructions, unsure of what to do next. Cara doesn’t follow up, doesn’t ask how it’s going, doesn’t realize they have nothing to do.

    Reflection: This is why regular check-ins and progress tracking are crucial. Not noticing that your team is idle means you’re not leading the team. It’s a waste of resources and creates frustration among team members.

    They don’t know who to ask for help

    When someone brings up that they don’t know who to go to with a question, she just says “ask someone,” but doesn’t even know who in the team has the answer.

    Reflection: A project leader doesn’t need to know everything – but you do need to know your team’s skills and who’s good at what. This kind of disconnection creates confusion and delays.

    Avoids conflict

    When a conflict arises in the team, she avoids it.

    Reflection: Conflicts are part of team dynamics. Being afraid of them or trying to hide from them only makes things worse. A project leader has to face conflict constructively – avoiding it just shows fear and weakens her authority.

    Poorly planned team building

    An experienced team member gently suggests that a team-building activity might help. Cara picks this up – which could have been a step in the right direction – but then sends out a meeting invite for drinks at a local pub, Friday evening from 18:00 to 22:00.

    Reflection: A leader should be proactive and intentional about team building – not reactive. This last-minute and poorly timed pub invite feels forced, superficial, and inconsiderate. It doesn’t account for team members who might have families, social anxiety, or don’t drink. And calling it a “meeting” just makes it even more awkward. If you’re going to do social bonding, do it thoughtfully and inclusively. This felt more like ticking a box.

    <b class=””>Shuts down learning opportunities

    A team member asks for training (on a relevant software tool), and Cara just says “not now, maybe after the project.”

    Reflection: This is short-sighted. If a team member is asking for training that could help them contribute better right now, that’s an opportunity – not a distraction. A good leader makes sure the team has the tools and knowledge to succeed.

    Overall summary

    Cara doesn’t trust herself, doesn’t trust her team, and seems afraid of her role as project leader. She’s uncomfortable making decisions, dodges conflict, hides behind email, and shows no clear plan. There’s no PMO structure in place – no roadmap, no milestones, no check-ins, and no clarity on responsibilities.

    Her leadership is passive and reactive. Instead of enabling and guiding the team, she’s watching from the sidelines, hoping someone else will take the lead. And when she does take action, like planning the team building, it’s rushed and tone-deaf – like she’s trying to look like a leader without actually leading.

    Bottom line: This isn’t just bad leadership. It’s non-leadership. The team is capable, but without a clear framework and a confident leader to rally around, they’re set up to underperform.

    Suggestion for Cara
    Cara need to do a lot of work here, learning and developing herself. First off she need some self-reflection and figure out her own strengths and weaknesses. In company to that she need to hone her soft skills and how to be a leader. She should seek out a mentor for coaching to help her with these things.
    Second, but not less important, she need to learn the hard skills. How to run setup a project framework, learn about clear goals, how to structure a project, what tools to use.
    Finally, she will need to go back to her stakeholders and figure out exactly what it is that they want, right now, all she has is a possibly unrealistic goal.

  • Alan Pinto

    PMO and Business Systems Manager at Avery Dennison Medical, 18 Jan 2026 at 08:42 AM

    Cara demonstrates numerous leadership and motivation failures. She sets an unrealistic goal of cutting costs by 50% with no performance impact without a clear plan, simply relying on team expertise and “magic” to happen, which leaves everyone directionless. Cara shows personal insecurity by confiding worries to one team member over coffee and lacks supportiveness, telling a struggling member to “figure it out” without guidance on who to ask, while ignoring workload imbalances where some team members have too little work. Her insistence on email-only communication despite co-location makes collaboration harder, she avoids conflict by taking an early lunch during a team argument, and her team-building attempt is poorly timed and optional, failing to build genuine cohesion. Finally, she blocks essential training requests by prioritising the project over development, demotivating the team further.

    One action Cara could take to improve her leadership and motivation is to implement regular, short stand-up meetings where the team collectively discusses progress, blockers, and workload distribution, fostering open communication, quick problem-solving, and a sense of shared ownership. This would replace her rigid email rules, address confusion over help-seeking, and prevent issues like idle time or unresolved conflicts from festering. By actively facilitating these sessions, Cara could build confidence, demonstrate support, and motivate the team through visibility and collective wins.

  • RACHAEL ELDRETTFlag

    Snr Manager, Operations at UP&E, 30 Jan 2026 at 03:01 PM

    Cara shows a real inexperience in project management and leadership. There are a lot of ways that she needs to improve her approach.

    Specific to motivation of her team though, communication seems to be an overarching issue. The ask to be included on all emails and for it to be the only method of communication has created a disengaged micro-managment culture that restricts open dialogue. As a result, team members are not speaking up when they have capacity, resolving problems efficiently, conflict resolution is being avoided and an understanding of what motivates both the team and individuals is being overlooked. By resetting the communication flow, this will help to alleviate these issues. For example, regular team in person chick ins to discuss workload, issues, documentation, team building etc encourages a collaborative and supportive approach.

  • Stephen OBrienFlag

    Business Excellence Consultant at BizEx Consulting, 25 Feb 2026 at 11:39 AM

    Identified Problems:

    · The Project goal is very generic and seems unrealistic – no baseline information provided to the team at the outset.

    · Cara has assembled a team based on them being experts in their fields – but has not outlined clearly their roles and responsibilities on the team.

    · The approach for success is based on hope – “Just find a way to work together and hopefully things work out”

    · Cara confided her insecurities of not being up to the challenge in one Team member – this undermines her credibility and inspiration to the team.

    · Cara is directing the team to always use email and copy her in everything …. This sends the message to the team that she doesn’t trust them and is perhaps wanting cover for when the project doesn’t succeed.

    · She hasn’t assessed the work load work and some have no tasks … she is not communicating or listening to her team members.

    · The Team are unclear on how to get support – a good PM should be able to assist the team when and how the need support…. Cara is not knowledgeable or willing to support the team when they do ask her for help

    · Cara avoids a conflict situation and allows it to develop instead of being involved and resolving at an early stage.

    · Declining a one-day training session that could help the project, help morale and improve skills for the team – Cara is very short sighted rather than looking at the longer term benefits. This sends the message to the team that being a member on this project will halt your development opportunities for the next year.

    One Action:

    Get back to basic Project Management approach and follow the PM steps. Cara needs to pause and reset the team as they are not going to be successful. She needs to use the basics of Project Management to get the members motivated and acting as a team. She needs to start by defining a realistic project scope based on data; define the roles and responsibilities of every member; communicate clearly and openly with the team and trust the team members to do their jobs; have regular team meetings and listen to feedback; find ways to support the team when they require support; get to know each team member and know what each person’s motivation is – use this to help improve the overall motivation of the team. Overall, Cara needs to become a much more engaged and involved Project Leader, listening, understanding and helping her team to succeed. 

  • Log in to reply.